Eagle Rare 10 Year Old Bourbon Review

Updated September 18, 2019

By Father John Rayls

Average Rating: B

Eagle Rare 10 Year Old Bourbon
(Credit: Buffalo Trace)

I initially stumbled across Eagle Rare 10 year by accident. The bottle looked interesting, a distributor suggested it, and it’s made by one of my favorite distilleries.

And did I mention the price? As a somewhat frugal consumer of all things whiskey, I’m always looking for the bang per buck return on any bottle purchased. It’s not that I don’t appreciate more expensive whiskey. I surely do. However, I can honestly say Buffalo Trace Distillery does not disappoint on price or the enjoyment factor with this offering.

Buffalo Trace Distillery is a well known name in the halls of Whiskeydom. They proudly proclaim themselves as the world’s most award winning distillery, and justifiably so. They have received awards and special proclamations numbering in the hundreds.

Beyond that, they trace their roots back over two hundred years, and received special recognition as a National Historic Landmark in 2013. They also happen to be the producers of several of my regular bourbons: 1) Blanton’s; 2) Col E.H. Taylor; 3) of course Eagle Rare 10 and 17 and a few other varieties that I enjoy periodically; 4) Sazerac Rye, 5) Elmer T. Lee, 6) George T. Stagg; 7) and the iconic Pappy Van Winkle. No other distillery comes close to filling my shelf as frequently or with as many beloved offerings as Buffalo Trace.

The Bourbon
Eagle Rare 10 year old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey is a complex treat for the senses, bottled at 90 proof. It has a reddish-orange/brown appearance, darker than most other whiskeys in my experience, and has a seductive viscosity that allows the bourbon to ooze down the sides of the glass when swirled.

The nose is certainly a sweet oaky aroma with hints of vanilla and leather. On the tongue, you will also pick up hints of licorice and honey in addition to the oak and vanilla with the presence of rye. This is a very smooth bourbon, but is much more than a simple gateway to better bourbons.

In my mind, there is absolutely no reason to purchase any other bourbon in the under $30 section. It tastes, smells and looks like a much more expensive whiskey and will not disappoint.

Addendum by Douglas Fraser

There is certainly a strong sense of American White Oak throughout this whiskey. Colored dark brown, on the nose are hints of oak, vanilla, leather, orange peel, and honey. The palate is a little spicy with more oak and vanilla in addition to some honey sweetness, hints of rye and cocoa. The finish is long and dry with a lingering spiciness until the end. Eagle Rare 10 is a Kentucky Straight Bourbon, bottled at 45% ABV, and can be an inexpensive whiskey that all may enjoy.

The Price
Pricing for Eagle Rare has held pretty steady since The Whiskey Reviewer first looked at it four years ago, with most online retailers floating in a range of $26 to $32.